10 signs you work in a culture of fear
Fear in the workplace rarely announces itself. Nobody calls a meeting to declare the workplace unsafe (although they may start a meeting by saying ‘this is a safe space’ when it’s patently not).
Fear tends to show up in smaller ways, in the things people stop doing or the way that they stop talking.
W. Edwards Deming worked this out in 1982. Point eight of his fourteen points for management was blunt: ‘drive out fear, so that everyone may work effectively’. He was writing about factory, shop and office floors decades before wellbeing became its own industry.
Fear, he warned, produces the wrong figures. People hand their boss the good news and hold back the rest. Sadly, in many workplaces, this is still a truth that employees recognise.
Here are ten signs that you might be working within a culture of fear:
1. The meeting waits for the boss. Before anyone offers a view, they check which way the senior person is leaning. Agreement arrives fast, always in their favour, which is not the same thing as agreement being real.
2. Bad news travels slowly, and secondhand. A problem is common knowledge on the ‘floor’ weeks before it reaches anyone able to do anything about it. By the time it surfaces, it is expensive or impossible to fix.
3. The cc list is doing a job. People copy half the organisation into routine emails, assembling evidence for the day someone comes looking to apportion blame.
4. Questions are heard as threats. Asking why something is done a certain way gets read as insubordination or disloyalty rather than interest.
5. Nobody owns a mistake until it is undeniable. Errors get buried or rebranded. This is the reverse of psychological safety, where people raise problems early because it is safe to do so.
6. The humour is toxic. Jokes get made about absent colleagues, or about the leadership behind closed doors, and are often prefaced by ‘I shouldn’t really say this…’ or ‘We shouldn’t laugh about this but…’.
7. People stay late to be seen. Presence, both in-person and online, stands in for active contribution. Whether the work got done is a separate question, and almost never the one being asked.
8. Feedback only runs downhill. The leader assesses everyone beneath them and hears nothing honest coming back. The upward channel is sometimes encouraged but never welcomed.
9. The exit interview is the most candid conversation anyone has had. People save their honesty for the moment they have nothing left to lose, which is far too late to be of any use.
10. Silence gets mistaken for consent. A room with no objections reads to the leader as a contented one. Usually it means people have worked out that speaking up costs more than sitting still.
None of this is inevitable, and none of it is hard to spot once you are looking. The awkward part is that fear suits the people at the top of the structure chart and spares them the friction of being challenged.
Deming's instruction still stands, yet many organisations have either chosen to ignore it or wear it. Last year, one in five employees worldwide were engaged at work. The other four had their reasons.
Download my new white paper ‘Making Culture Change Stick’ to find out more about how you can build, change or retain a great place to work at www.colindellis.com/culture-papers
