In June 2022, Anne Whyte published her independent review of gymnastics in the UK, covering 2008 to 2020. It described a coach-led culture of fear in which young gymnasts were frightened of the people responsible for them. ITV News reported that the review also criticised the governing body's insular culture.
Whyte also found that a culture of fear left many gymnasts too scared to report abuse. That is what insularity does. It removes the comparison that would tell people that something might be wrong.
It’s like a glass box. From the outside you can see in - the policies, the values on the wall, the statements about a commitment to welfare. From the inside, the view is of the other walls. The same managers, the same habits and the same people telling you this is how it is done. Nobody inside can see what normal looks like elsewhere.
This is not confined to sport (and it’s also worth mentioning that Gymnastics has worked hard to rebuild trust since the review). Any organisation that hires from the same pool, promotes people who ‘fit’ and listens mainly to its own leaders can drift into the same place.
The values may be absolutely fine. The problem is that often, nobody outside the box is checking whether the people inside live by them.
This is the benefit that outside eyes can bring. Ask someone who does not report into the leadership team to read the exit interviews, the performance reviews, the safety statistics and the complaints data. You could even ask your newest starters what has surprised them in their first weeks of work, before they stop noticing.
The safest culture is one that expects to be looked at - from all sides of the box - continually.